PDA

View Full Version : guys which is more stable and has fewer flaws? G73sw or G74sx ? Heeeelp!



luvgood
09-15-2011, 02:50 AM
hi guys im really excited to get one of this rigs but im thinking twice if i'll go for the G74sx because of the issues/problems owners post online.. and at the same time im not that of a fan of the G73sw because it has lower specs than the G74sx.. some told me to get the alienware M17x or MSI 780R, but I love the ROG more.. and seriously i dont want to choose other brands because of the flaws/issues that ROG is having.. :(

ROG ftw!

thanks

jorlanm
09-15-2011, 03:06 AM
Both are pretty good...the MSI GT780DX has a GTX 570m GPU though...Otherwise the G73sw and the G74sx has the GTX 460m and the GTX 560m which is not that faster than the Fermi...

luvgood
09-15-2011, 03:11 AM
oh thanks jorlan but if you have more input between the comparison of those two G73sw and G74sx.. which is more buggy?

Br4nd3n
09-15-2011, 03:15 AM
The g74 is in no doubt a better machine. It has updated hardware, which therefor makes it more dominant over the g73. I recently upgraded my g73 to the G74sx-A1, and it is surely a noticeable change.

luvgood
09-15-2011, 03:19 AM
that helps a lot br4nd3n but how about the keyboard issues?? is your g74 ok?

jorlanm
09-15-2011, 04:14 AM
I wouldnt realy say updated hardware...everything else is the same with the G73sw and the G74sx besides the GPU...the G74Sxhas the 560m but the G73 has a subwoofer

DSKTechie
09-15-2011, 08:07 AM
Just picked up(and am posting from) the G74sx after wrestling with this very question, here are some of the things that went into my decision. The GPU was a major deciding factor because it is one area that cannot be conveniently upgraded to extend the life/power of the machine. For this reason I went with one of the stripped down versions, no BlueRay, only one 500mb HD, etc. but avoided the BBK7 because it has the neutered GPU and Display.

As far as the keyboard goes, I updated the ATK/BIOS right off so I can't speak to any errors with the default system. From what I have seen, this has fixed almost any keyboard issue posted, at least for those who reported their results after having tried it. Since then the only issue I've encountered has to do with my lack of accuracy while getting accustomed to a new keyboard style.

On the audio side, adjusting the THX TruStudio every reboot is mildly annoying, but that is a short term software issue and thus wasn't a factor for the decision. There is a noticeable, if slight, lack of base, but the overall speaker sound quality is quite acceptable. I use earbuds or a gaming headset most of the time so my experience in this area is not terribly extensive and YMMV.

Great experience so far, though I still have a ways to go in order to put this through its paces for gaming performance. The most pleasant surprise was the lack of bloatware to uninstall, I was all set to do a clean wipe but it really does not seem necessary.

That was a bit more long-winded than anticipated, but I hope some of it has helped.

edit:To answer your question directly, the 73sw has been out long enough to work out the kinks and is likely the more stable at the moment. However the minor nature of issues with the 74sx and the rate that past ones have been fixed makes it the better choice in my eyes.

Br4nd3n
09-15-2011, 06:53 PM
I haven't had a single issue with my Sx-A1 yet. The only thing I have a concern with is the audio, but I use a nice gaming headset with Dolby surround sound anyway. The G74 has a better GPU and that should be your deciding factor IMO.

panzerkiller13
09-16-2011, 03:47 PM
How much Of a difference do you notice in the audio of the G74 as opposed to the G73? Is it really worth choosing the 73 over it? I've also seen that the 74 has better battery life, but that was only one review and they did not include the G73SW in it. Anyone got firsthand experience with that?

korre
09-16-2011, 04:29 PM
Correct me if i'm wrong. All I know is that the 460m GPU has more cuda cores in it (192) and the 560m has 128bit, so the 460m performs better in games.

jorlanm
09-16-2011, 04:40 PM
The GTX 460m and the GTX 560m is exactly the same specs, just that the GTX560m runs at higher frequncy resulting in an average 10% increase, but The GTX 460m (fermi) has higher Temperature treshhold (105c and still stable for the GTX 460m according to nVidia and 100c limit for GTX560m) hotter...unless you get a G53sx thats configured for 128-bit...

Ransom
10-07-2011, 03:53 PM
Someone please correct me if I'm wrong, but the G74 is completely smooth on the bottom, and the G73 is not. For me, this is a big factor. The G73 has intake vents on the bottom, while the G74 does not. Because of this, I don't ever have to worry about blocking a cooling vent on my G74 while it sits on my lap or on my bed or on the couch. It is completely smooth and there are no vents. For me this is a HUGE plus in getting the G74 over ANY other laptop.

Ransom

Chastity@ASUS
10-07-2011, 10:45 PM
Correct, the air intakes on the G74 is under the lip of the lcd panel. Just don't let any comforters block the rear exhaust, and you should be fine.