View Poll Results: What is your preference regarding motherboard LAN controllers?

Voters
14. You may not vote on this poll
  • the choice of vendor for the LAN controller doesn't matter

    3 21.43%
  • I use an add-on network card

    0 0%
  • Marvell

    0 0%
  • Intel

    10 71.43%
  • Atheros

    1 7.14%
  • Realtek

    0 0%
Results 1 to 7 of 7
  1. #1
    I left ASUS, please contact cl-scott Array
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Reputation
    15
    Posts
    155

    ** Official ASUS Poll & Discussion - LAN Controllers **

    Hello ROG'ers!

    I have another poll and discussion that I'd like to get your feedback on to help us make some decisions related to motherboard network controllers (NICs). As always, we come to the forums first to try to get the widest reach of customer input and feedback.

    I'm sure many of you have noticed that the integration of Intel NICs on our motherboards has become more and more prevalent of late on our motherboards (mainly Intel chipset motherboards) and there are many reasons for this which I will explain in this post. However, the point of this thread is to get your feedback on this and see if this is something that is important enough if your eyes for us to continue doing.

    We included Intel Gigabit LAN on many of our Z68 boards, Z77 boards, and on all of our X79 boards. One reason this decision was made is the robustness of the driverset and the various options included in the Intel LAN chipset allowing power users as well as the average user to customize his/her online experience. Some of these options are Advanced Networking Services Teaming, VLANs, fine-grained control of link speed and duplex, Identify Adapter option, different packet options for specifying preferred frame size of certain data transfer scenarios, offloading of certain tasks to the NIC hardware because the NIC hardware can process certain things faster than the OS can and thus free up CPU cycles, etc.

    Another reason we often use Intel LAN controllers is because of its higher degree of interoperability and compatibility with different types of software and operating system environments.

    The third advantage that the Intel controller offers is its high level of performance. With all of the new software titles and applications coming out everyday that involve sending more and more data over a network, we feel the performance factor advantage to be a very important one to the majority of computer users out there. In our testing, as well as Intel's, we've noticed a higher level of performance with Intel LAN controllers, especially with larger packet sizes.

    Of course the reason why we started this thread is to get your feedback on these items and find out whether you're experiencing these same advantages with Intel LAN controllers as well as how much of an impact the choice of NIC vendor makes when you consider purchasing a motherboard. For the poll, the information we would like to get is whether or not the manufacturer's choice of LAN controller makes a difference to you, if more often than not, you purchase an add-on LAN card, or if you do use the on-board LAN and do think the choice of vendor makes a difference, then which vendor you prefer. Along with your selection of LAN controller preference, please also post why you chose what you chose and your experiences good and/or bad regarding LAN controllers.

    Thanks again for your valuable feedback which will help us to put out products catered more to your needs and wants.

  2. #2
    ROG Guru: White Belt Array Lilkka's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Reputation
    15
    Posts
    111

    I picked Intel, and thats because since my old P5Q pro board, swapping to the Gene Z/Gen 3 i instantly saw a difference in every internet operations. I also prefer to know my internet (network controller) is being provided by one of the best chip designers on the market they know what they are doing and have for years. I get iffy if i find a board with a bad network controller and i actually walk away from it because the internet for me is the in the top 3 things of what i NEED and WANT out of my PC, I definatly have seen the difference in the internet and the way it is all managed,

    Intel all the way for me, every new option and its longevity is what i find perfect & its reliable and no hassle drivers.
    PC Specs: Intel 2500k - 4.6GHZ (Overclocked) 7 Stepping CPU.
    Corsair Vengance 16GB 4GB Kit @ 1600MHZ 9/9/9/24/2 - now overclocked: 1866 9/10/9/27/2- ATI 6850 GFX - (OC 855mhz/1165) -
    Maximus Gene Z/Gen 3 3305 BIOS, Voltages: Ram 1.6 - CPU 1.360 / 75% Vdroop. VCCISO 1.1500.
    Antec 300 Case - Sata II 5400 RPM 500GB Master HDD.

    RoG Member! And Proud!

    Lilkka

  3. #3
    Kotetsu Array Black4's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Reputation
    11
    Posts
    179

    I wouldn't purchase an add-on LAN card unless the on-board wasn't adequate for a special application, like a server. In general, I would't want to give up a card slot for a LAN card and think the interface could be designed better/faster if it were integral (on-board).

    Overall performance and compatibility would be my goals, rather than any particular NIC vendor. Intel is a trusted brand, but if Gigabit LAN were higher performance (more durable, etc.) for the typical application of the mainboard, I'd want the NIC vendor's components that offered the best network communication performance.
    A Republic of Gamers heart.

    | olive drab Vengeance C70 chassis | Win 10 64-bit | Maximus V GENE board | i7 2600K | Viper3 1866 MHz memory | Corsair H80 CPU liquid-cooler | R-O-G HD7970 Matrix Platinum card | striping RAID array | Samsung 245BW 24" monitor |

  4. #4
    TeamROG Moderator Array xeromist PC Specs
    xeromist PC Specs
    Laptop (Model)Dell Inspiron 15 7567
    MotherboardMSI x470 Gaming Plus
    ProcessorAMD 2600X
    Memory (part number)16GB Crucial Ballistix Elite 3600
    Graphics Card #1ASUS GTX 1080 Strix
    MonitorBenQ BL3200PT
    Storage #1Intel 600p NVMe
    CPU CoolerWraith
    Casecustom Antec 900
    Power SupplyCorsair HX1000
    Keyboard Logitech Orion Spark
    Mouse Logitech MX500
    Headset Plantronics 777 with Oregon Aero upgrade
    xeromist's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Reputation
    301
    Posts
    7,472

    I generally have my network equipment for longer than any given motherboard so I want a new motherboard to have optimal compatibility with all of my existing equipment. My personal experience has been that Intel has been the most hassle free in this respect.
    * Support disease research with Folding@Home *

    < < < Click the drop-down above my avatar for my PC specs!

  5. #5
    ROG Guru: Gold Belt Array Menthol PC Specs
    Menthol PC Specs
    MotherboardM 10 Apex / XI gene
    Processor8700K / 9900K
    Memory (part number)2x8 Gskill Trident Z 4266/2x2x8 Gskill Trident Z 4500
    Graphics Card #1RTX 2080ti / GTX 1060
    Sound CardSoundBlaster Ae5 / Onboard
    MonitorBENQ 32" 4K
    Storage #1Intel 900p 480GB/Samsung 960 Pro 1TB
    Storage #2Intel 750 1.2TB/Plextor 1 TB 2X 950 Pro
    CPU CoolerCorsair H150i AIO / H1110i
    CaseCorsair 740 ? Lian Li Air
    Power SupplyCorsair AX 1200i / AX 1200i
    Keyboard Corsair
    Mouse ASUS Strix
    Headset HyperX Cloud Alpha
    Mouse Pad ASUS
    Headset/Speakers Logitech Z906
    OS 10 X64 Pro
    Network RouterVerizon Fios
    Accessory #1 Intel Wifi BT pcie card
    Accessory #2 Red Bull
    Accessory #3 English Breakfast Tea
    Menthol's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Reputation
    241
    Posts
    4,547

    I don't know much about the different settings on NIC controllers, but prior to this R4E board I had been using bigfoot killer cards, regardless of all the reviews either praising or slamming the killer cards, I can't back up any facts, I just got a smooth online game experience with them, I owned the original Killer and have the 2100 that I used from my R3E sitting in my closet simply because of the way the lanes are on the R4E to the R3E, I could have 2 video cards in x16, a sound card and NIC card on the R3E, on the R4E, I had to leave the NIC card out to keep 2 video cards at X16 and the audio card. The Intel onboard NIC works very well as far as I can tell as good as the killer and would not like to go to something of less quality or performance. At least on the ROG board I would prefer the best of the best. My 2 cents but what do I know

  6. #6
    AntiMatter Guru ROG Array chrsplmr's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Reputation
    295
    Posts
    6,113

    I prefer intel onboard. They are the best on the market at this point.
    For me that is what should always be found on any ROG product ..
    the best available .. today.

  7. #7
    imMortal Kombatant Array Myk SilentShadow PC Specs
    Myk SilentShadow PC Specs
    MotherboardASUS Rampage IV Formula
    ProcessorIntel i7 3930K
    Memory (part number)8GB Corsair XMS3 1600
    Graphics Card #1ASUS Radeon 7970 3GD5
    Sound CardROG Xonar Phoebus
    MonitorSamsung SyncMaster SA300
    Storage #1Corsair Neutron 128GB
    Storage #2Seagate 2TB
    CPU CoolerCorsair A50 Pro Air Cooler
    CaseBitFenix Merc Alpha
    Power SupplyThermaltake Litepower 700W
    Keyboard Alienware TactX Keyboard
    Mouse Tesoro Gandiva H1L
    OS Win7 Ultimate x64
    Myk SilentShadow's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Reputation
    266
    Posts
    5,241

    I used to use only Realtek NIC's (add in cards) for my networking needs, until I set up a wireless network then suddenly the G Class Realtek card started to act really bad(updated drivers, uninstalled and reinstalled, swapped the card in PCI Lanes) and it just was unable to do what I needed it to do. So I bought a Netgear USB Wireless Adapter....what a big mistake that was. ANYWAYS!!! before I get in trouble for steering the thread off course, i'll say that with what I have been reading (in the RoG Forums and elsewhere) Intel seem to be making the best NIC's and onboard adapter's....so i'd say you guys should stick with them

    P.S RoG/ASUS should make Wireless Router/Modems...that way I can still stay wirelessly networked and not have to buy 2 seperate units plus an add-on card/USB Adapter :hint hint: Starting from the next planned model from the RT-N66U....so I can buy the EA-N66 Adapter
    Last edited by Myk SilentShadow; 05-08-2012 at 12:27 PM.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •