joshindaphils wrote:
So what is wrong with your nearly identical thead here: https://rog.asus.com/forum/showthread.php?74509-G751JT-vs-GT72

There is no need for a new thread, please consolidate the conversation. All of those things were already discussed in your old thread as well. You are not going to get any significant number of people that have solid experience with both machines, and I would bet most of them commented on your old thread already.

You even answer your own question number 2 with you first list of things you know heheh. It's okay man just take a deep breath and click order. Flip a coin if you need to 😛

I would suggest going to a brick and mortar store and put hands on each if you can. That may sway your opinion more than anything.

It's a big decision you know, and I'd rather not flip a coin. I guess I'm just waiting for enough people that say go for one or the other. Also wish I could lock the other thread since I feel this one is more professional...

Edit by cl-Albert: Okay, other thread has been closed and a link to this thread provided.

Also, if you it makes sense to you, you may want to tell us what things are most important to you or are deal-breakers although it's possible you may not know some of these things until after you buy and use the notebook (you may want to purchase from a reseller with a good return policy in this case?). Good luck!

Well your in an Asus forum, we all like our G notebooks if you want someone to talk you into the MSI go on over to their forum or for real diversity then Notebook review Forum

Clintlgm wrote:
Well your in an Asus forum, we all like our G notebooks if you want someone to talk you into the MSI go on over to their forum or for real diversity then Notebook review Forum

I've posted this on the MSI forum as well. Just wanna get some answers from Asus people to why they like or dislike the G751 series !?

Ok then I bought my G75VW in July 2012 I have a RMA right off with the right speaker not working at all. This RMA was wasted as all they did was image the original image to my hard drive/SSD and send it back. The right speaker still did not work. Some time in early 2013 I started having issues with the track pad and keyboard I this time Started the RMA and then PM cl-albert and informed him of my issues including the right speaker not working. This RMA took about 3 weeks a new mother board, track pad, keyboard and cables were all replaced if I remember right they notebook has worked flawlessly ever since I guess about 38 months now. It still serves me well although I usually buy an new one every three years, I see some issues with the G751JY that kept me from getting this one however I most likely will buy with the next generation coming up. I have one last comment When I buy the next one I will pay a little bit extra and purchase through a custom vendor where I'll get the Pro version of windows, custom repasting of CPU and GPU the latest M.2 main OS driver Also at least some of then run a though break in testing. I feel that this should eliminate most of the issues we see here in these forums. And Yep its probably going to cost me a few hundred more for this service but my odds of having a RMA will be really slimmed down. I work remotely and having to RMA my notebook really put me in a bind and I lose money if I can't find a replacement to get me through the RMA Time. I really got spoiled with Gateway they would just send you replacement FedEx next day if there tech support couldn't get you going again. All I would have to do put my hard drive and RAM in and I was back in business. I went through 5 of there notebooks just for that reason. When that went away I looked around and Asus M70SA looked good to me. My only complaint was Vista Asus never did support Win 7 for that model. It lasted me 4 + years to when I bought the G75VW . Even with the horrible tech support and Repair stations nightmares I will buy Asus again with out any other thought,

Well I have never been on MSI Gaming Forum, are you getting technical answers over there. I think that these forums alone would be good reason to buy Asus Gaming. What are the work around for their overheating issues? Are they even actually having temp issues. Upgradability are you really up for paying the cost to upgrade a Video card? Or 2 in SLI? 2 or 3 years down the road. I think you'll more likely be ready for a new notebook anyway.