THE CASE
For all you detectives out there.
Hi, I'm a Dutch game developer, currently stationed in Germany for a short period.
I purchased my G750JX at a Dutch shop and am still my warranty period.
The original adopter that came with my notebook was the
FA180PM111. (Sturdy thing, INPUT 100-240V, 50-60Hz, 2.5A | OUTPUT: 19.5V, 9.23A)
I think I must've ran over the DC cable with my office chair, there's no way to verify this, but one day it didn't work.
When testing the adopter at a PC repair shop, they confirmed that it no longer supplies power and that there's probably an issue with the cable.
Though I could return it to ASUS and get a new one in my warranty, they warned me that if the adopter broke because of "user inflicted damage" I would be obligated to pay the research fee of 75EUR and additionally pay the full price of a new adopter. (Also, it would take up to about two weeks until I could get the item returned.)
So, if I felt lucky, I could send it to ASUS and hope they won't check it and send me a new one in return for free. Or risk a 75 EUR fine and two weeks of no adopter.
WHAT I BOUGHTNot feeling very lucky and in quite a hurry, I searched for a replacement on the internet and found multiple resellers on Ebay who offered an "ORIGINAL FA180PM111 ADOPTER". However, these always came with the same product image of a similar looking model, called the
ADP-180MB F.
Not thinking much of it, I eventually purchased the best deal I could find, specifically asked the reseller to box the titulair product and waited for my parcel.
(Place where I bought it:
http://www.ebay.de/itm/Netzteil-180-Watt-Original-FA180PM111-/151821158418?hash=item23593f0812:g:nnY... )
Two days later, I get the
ADP-180MB F adopter in my mailbox.
Looks almost exactly the same and has almost identical specs: INPUT 100-240V, 50-60Hz,
2.34A | OUTPUT: 19.5V, 9.23A
Only other difference is that the DC power cable is allot bulkier than the
FA180PM111 model. The cord is less flexible and the jack/pin is housed in a bulkier casing.
So the input ampere is lower and the finish is allot less pleasant.
To me, it seems like an inferior model of the same product.
WHAT ASUS SAIDMildly annoyed I called ASUS, but they say they can't help me based on model numbers and push me to use an official reseller. But by now I'm more cautious. Official reseller also doesn't provide any proper product images and is allot more expensive. So for all I know I'll just get the
ADP-180MB F again. Also, it will take about two weeks before the product should reach me and I really need this PC for my work.
WHAT ARE THE RESULTSSo before I return this adopter and ask for a refund, and start doing business with the preferred ASUS supplier, I wanted to test this thing out and more importantly, ask you guys for your help and opinion.
When I tried the
ADP-180MB F out on my G750JX yesterday it worked without much trouble.
PC steadily charges while using it, though it seems to stick somewhere at 97% - while the power indicator has a green light. (Fully charged.)
Only solution is when I close the laptop and leave it for a moment.
While connected and on High Performance setting, I ran the Witcher 3 without any problems.
The PC's manual merely states that the PC requires an adopter with the following specs:
INPUT VOLTAGE: 100-240Vac
INPUT FREQUENCY: 50-60Hz
OUTPUT CURRENT: 180W (19.5V, 9.23A)
OUTPUT VOLTAGE: 19V
So the input ampere should be no problem, it's the output that matters, right?
Also, what do you guys think, should I return this adopter and find another reseller?=== REFERENCES ===Example EBAY offers that announce to sell the FA180PM111 model, but post a different model number in their product picture.
1. Asus FA180PM111 Netzteil 180 Watt original
http://www.amazon.de/Asus-FA180PM111-Netzteil-Watt-original/dp/B00G5UVLE82. Asus FA180PM111 ac-adapter 180 watt original
http://www.amazon.com/Asus-FA180PM111-ac-adapter-watt-original/dp/B00G5UVLE83. Netzteil 180 Watt -Original- FA180PM111
http://www.ebay.de/itm/Netzteil-180-Watt-Original-FA180PM111-/151821158418?hash=item23593f0812:g:nnY...4. Even this flimsy YouTube review uses the wrong model number in its image.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5QZ_os_L7fc